Former Indian spinner Murali Kartik questioned team management after Axar Patel batted ahead of Ishan Kishan in the fifth ODI against New Zealand at Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui on Sunday.
The visitors were reduced to 34-3 when the Gautam Gambhir-led think tank decided to promote Patel to number five position ahead of Kishan. Earlier in the series, Patel had also batted ahead of KL Rahul at number five spot.
Meanwhile, Patel and Kishan both top-scored for India with 46 runs each in the final ODI.
“Why was Ishan Kishan suddenly pushed down? What sort of versatility are they expecting from him? I understand he’s not in the top 3, but to be pushed down to 6, what was the thought there? If it was Axar coming ahead to protect Kishan against the new ball, it’s like a night watchman in a day game,” said Kartik on Cricbuzz.
Kartik said he would not back Kishan as a finisher and he is more suited to the top order.
“I wouldn’t think of Kishan as a finisher. If anything, I would think of bumping him up the order because he’s an opener and bats in the top 3 in T20 cricket. So I actually want him up there in the batting order. Why do you want him as a finisher when you have Hardik Pandya and the rest? I don’t look at Kishan as a finisher at all.”
On the other hand, former Indian wicket-keeper batsman Dinesh Karthik said Axar Patel and Ishan Kishan’s batting was a positive for the visitors.
“The way Axar batted with intent was a positive. He has had his woes against pacers, which he countered nicely. Kishan once again showed why he’s rated so highly. He hasn’t put a foot wrong since his comeback. He batted in a position he hasn’t played too often but still applied himself and played the right shots. He got out because he was running out of partners and had to farm the strike and take on the pacers one too many times,” said Karthik (via the aforementioned source).
India was bowled out for 209 runs in the final game.

