India’s ODI series in New Zealand has exposed several weaknesses in their batting lineup. The team struggled to chase 143 in the opening match, scraped home in a target of 110 after losing seven wickets, and then suffered collapses for 89 and 209 in the final two games.
For a team preparing for a World Cup, these are worrying signs.
Rohit Sharma managed just 30 runs in the series. His struggles against pace, seam and bounce were evident, raising questions about his ability to deliver in conditions similar to those expected in South Africa.
Virat Kohli’s numbers were also disappointing. Barring one match, his shot selection left much to be desired. More concerning is the fact that his last ODI century outside Asia came seven years ago. For a batter expected to anchor India’s World Cup campaign, that is a statistic worth examining.
Shreyas Iyer had an equally difficult series. He looked vulnerable against the New Zealand attack and failed to provide the middle-order stability India needed. His place in the World Cup squad must now come under scrutiny.
Among the other batters, Ruturaj Gaikwad played two matches but failed to make a convincing impression. Ishan Kishan, also featuring in two games, arguably looked the most assured of India’s batting options. His performances should strengthen his case for a longer run.
Naman Dhir had a disappointing series, while Axar Patel’s 46 in the final match was a welcome contribution. However, barring that innings, he did little to justify his promotion ahead of KL Rahul in the batting order.
Gambhir’s criticism of the senior batters is therefore understandable. Scoring heavily on flat pitches at home is one thing; adapting to conditions that offer assistance to bowlers is quite another.
India still have 11 months before the World Cup, which leaves time for corrections. But the selectors and team management need to identify their best batting combination soon.
The question is no longer simply about individual form. It is about whether India’s batting lineup has the technique, temperament and consistency to compete for a World Cup in South Africa.


